Thứ Năm, 3 tháng 10, 2013

Diana director 'devastated' by reviews

Diana director 'devastated' by reviews


Naomi Watts as Princess DianaOscar-nominated actress Naomi Watts plays Princess Diana in the film

Related Stories

The director of Diana says he has "no regrets", despite the film's poor reception in the UK.
Oliver Hirschbiegel told the BBC that the movie's critical mauling was "devastating, but when you make a film you don't think about the reactions".
The Telegraph described the film "a special class of awful", while the Mirror called it "cheap and cheerless".
Hirschbiegel admitted the reviews had put off audiences, but he still hoped people would "make their own minds up".
"In all the other places where it's opened - in Poland, the Czech Republic, Turkey and Slovakia - it's been very strong," he said.
"I think for the British, Diana is still a trauma they haven't come to terms with."
Starring Naomi Watts, the film depicts Princess Diana in the final years of her life, with a focus on her affair with heart surgeon Hasnat Khan, played by Lost's Naveen Andrews.
Oliver HirschbiegelOliver Hirschbiegel says his depiction of Diana is "very un-British"
It entered the UK chart at number five in its opening weekend, taking £623,000 at the box office. This week, it dropped to number nine.
Hirschbiegel, who previously made Downfall, a German-language film about the last days of Hitler, called his experiences with Diana "deja vu, because it has the same reactions in the UK as Downfall had in Germany on release".
"I hope it is a matter of stepping back and looking at it afresh in a year or so, because it is a very British story and I am a very German director."
He added that Diana "was the most complex character I have ever tried to depict - more complex than Hitler. The one thing they both had in common was they were born actors".
Earlier this week, at the Zurich Film Festival, Hirschbiegel described the film as "very un-British" and described the critical reaction as harking back "to what newspapers like the Daily Mail would write about her back then - really vile things. So I guess I succeeded."
The film has been sold to distributors in more than 40 countries and will be released in the US on 1 November, 2013.

Making Time: Can we teach kindness?

Making Time: Can we teach kindness?


Two people holding hands
Would you give up your seat to someone unable to stand or protect a stranger from attack? We may say we would, but we don't always. Is this just human nature, or can we be taught to be kind?
Early one morning in March 1964, a young woman called Kitty Genovese returned home to her New York apartment and was attacked and killed by an armed assailant.
According to newspaper reports at the time, dozens of neighbours watched the murder take place just outside their windows - but no-one came to her aid.
Genovese's fate, they claimed, was symbolic of the cold and careless society we had come to inhabit, and painted a stark picture of social decay.
Although the precise details have since been called into question, the case has come to represent what social scientists call "the bystander effect", or the "volunteer's dilemma".
Kitty GenoveseThe murder of Kitty Genovese in 1964 sparked the idea of the "bystander effect"
When surrounded by other people, the theory suggests, we become less likely to intervene and help our fellow citizens.
Research being carried out in the US and the UK, however, is testing whether this type of behaviour is hardwired into our nature or can be modified through training.

The murder of Kitty Genovese

  • 28-year-old Kitty Genovese was stabbed to death on 13 March 1964 in New York
  • Initial reports indicated 38 people had heard or seen parts of the attack but none had intervened
  • A later version of accounts stated that witnesses had not been aware of the entire incident
  • It nevertheless prompted an investigation into what became known as the "bystander effect"
In a recent experiment, a team of scientists from Northeastern University in Boston advertised a meditation class and recruited a set of volunteers. Half of the respondents went along to the sessions, while the other half were told that they were on a waiting list instead.
For those who attended, the course involved different forms of compassion meditation which has its roots in Tibetan Buddhism. In essence, the classes were designed to encourage people to pick up on shared characteristics rather than their differences, says social psychology professor David DeSteno, who helped carry out the research.
Once the classes were complete, all of the respondents - including those still on the waiting list - were subject to a real-world test that they were unaware was taking place.
One by one, they were called to attend a meeting. Before it began, they entered a waiting room with three chairs. Two were occupied by actors, leading the participant to sit down at the third.
Chair test A posed photograph of the compassion test conducted by David DeSteno's team
"After a couple of minutes, a woman would walk in on crutches - wincing with pain - and lean against the wall. The actors looked away and didn't give up their chairs," says DeSteno.
Of those who had received the compassion training, around half stood up to offer their chair to the woman, and for those who had not, the figure was just 15%.
"The underlying argument in all of this is that if we can get people to see similarities instead of differences, their willingness to help will increase," he says.

Making Time

A BBC News Magazine series about people who do things for good causes
In northern California, another group of researchers has turned to virtual reality to investigate what causes us to help other people.
"A lot of the work we do asks the question 'If I give someone a very intense virtual experience, how does it affect their behaviour in the real world?'" says Jeremy Bailenson, a professor at Stanford University's human interaction laboratory.
The team devised a "Superman" test in which subjects donned virtual reality goggles and were dropped into an evacuated city.
Some were told that they had superhuman powers, and had to deliver a shot of insulin to a diabetic child stranded somewhere nearby. "You lift your arms above your head to fly, and rotate your body to go in another direction - just like Superman in the movies," says Bailenson.
Other participants were taken on a tourists' helicopter ride around the city instead.
Once the child had been found, or the helicopter ride was complete, the participants sat through an interview that they were not told was part of the experiment. Halfway through the meeting, the researcher would knock over a pot of stationery on a desk.
Virtual reality exercise The 'Superman' virtual reality test conducted by Jeremy Bailenson and his team
Interviewees who had been given superhuman powers in the virtual world rushed to help clean up the mess more often than those who had not - many of whom did nothing at all.
The findings suggest that the more empowered people feel, the greater their propensity to show kindness to others.
In the UK, another study has attempted to go one step further - by introducing the idea of aggression and violence into the equation.

The Magazine on compassion

Tom Shakespeare asks whether compassion is important in healthcare
Ma

My Nazi grandfather, Amon Goeth, would have shot me

My Nazi grandfather, Amon Goeth, would have shot me

Jennifer Teege
Jennifer Teege was shocked to discover her grandfather was a Nazi concentration camp commandant. Her mother never told her, and as a child she never knew her father - a Nigerian student with whom her mother had a brief affair. This is her story.
Five years ago in northern Germany, in Hamburg, I was in the central library and I came across a book. It was wrapped in a red cover and for some reason I was immediately drawn to it.
The title, translated into English, was I Have to Love My Father, Right? and it had a small picture of a woman on the front who looked faintly familiar.
So I took the book and quickly went through it. There were a lot of photos and as I looked at the book I felt something was wrong.
Amon Goeth and Monika HertwigTeege's grandfather Amon Goeth and her mother Monika Hertwig
At the end, the author summed up some details about the woman on the cover and her family, and I realised they were a perfect match with what I knew about my own biological family.

Amon Leopold Goeth 1908-1946

Amon Goeth holding a gun
  • Born in Vienna
  • Commandant at the Plaszow concentration camp near Krakow from 1943 to 1944
  • Tried before the Polish Supreme Court and sentenced to death for the mass murder of Jews
  • Hanged in Krakow in 1946
  • Character played by Ralph Fiennes in the film Schindler's List
So at that point I understood that this was a book about my family history.
The woman in the picture was my mother, and her father was Amon Goeth, the commandant of Plaszow concentration camp near Krakow.
My mother had told me nothing, but I did not grow up with my mother - she gave me up as a very small child.
A few weeks after I was born I was put in a children's home where I sometimes saw my mother. Then I grew up in a foster family that adopted me when I was seven years old. So I saw my mother until the age of seven but after that we had no contact - except for once.
This was when I was in my 20s and she probably did not tell me anything at this point because she wanted to protect me - she thought it would be better if I did not know about my real past, about the truth, about my family, about my grandfather.
Amon Goeth in uniform, riding a horseAmon Goeth at Plaszow
I was completely shocked when I found out - it was like the carpet was ripped from under my feet.
I couldn't do anything. I went home, I took the book with me, and at home I read it cover to cover. There were details about my mother, my grandmother and my grandfather, Amon Goeth.
I slowly started to understand the impact of what I had read. Growing up as an adopted child I did not know anything about my past, or only very very little. Then to be confronted with information like this was so overwhelming.
It was weeks, a month, until I really started to recover.
I had seen the film Schindler's List, in which Ralph Fiennes plays my grandfather. I knew he was playing a man called Goeth but I had not made the connection - it never occurred to me that we were related.
Ralph Fiennes as Amon GoethRalph Fiennes as Amon Goeth in Schindler's List
I think if I had known all of this when I was younger, it would have been easier because I would have had a chance to integrate it into my life. Getting the information so spontaneously, so out of the blue, it was almost impossible to make it fit in with my understanding of who I am.

Find out more

  • Jennifer Teege spoke to World Update on the BBC World Service.
It was very distressing to know that Amon Goeth and I are genetically linked. I feel part of it, but still there is a distance - which is a difference between me and my mother, because she grew up with her own mother (with my grandmother) and for her it was difficult to leave the past behind.
I have tried not to leave the past behind but put it in a place where it belongs, which means not to ignore it, but not to let it overshadow my life.
I am not a reflection of this part of my family story but I am still very connected to it. I try to find a way to integrate it into my life.
It is a story that is very unique and very unusual, and a story that has a deeper meaning. It is more about the universal question of how to deal with the weight of the past on the present - and it should show that it is possible to gain personal freedom from the past.
Jennifer Teege spoke to World Update on theBBC World Service. Her book is called Amon My Grandfather Would Have Shot Me.
You can follow the Magazine on Twitter and on Facebook

More on This Story

Colombian government 'ready to reintegrate rebels'

Colombian government 'ready to reintegrate rebels'

A screenshot from an ACR video explaining the government's reintegration programmeThe ACR tries to encourage rebels and paramilitaries to reintegrate into society

Related Stories

Colombia has said it is ready to reintegrate thousands of demobilised rebels into society, as peace talks between Farc rebels and government negotiators enter their 15th round.
The Colombian Agency for Reintegration (ACR) director said the body could look after double the number of demobilised rebels it currently mentored.
Director Alejandro Eder told the BBC it had an "emergency reaction plan".
According to Mr Eder, the ACR is ready to receive up to 40,000 ex-combatants.
The government estimates there are just 7,800 active Farc rebels, with approximately another 10,000 people on the margins of the group.
The National Liberation Army (ELN), Colombia's second-largest rebel group, is estimated to have just under 1,500 fighters.
Ready and willing

Start Quote

Alejandro Eder
They're coming from a completely different society and you essentially have to train them about everything”
Alejandro EderDirector, Colombian Agency for Reintegration
The government has been holding peace talks with the Farc since November 2012 and recently signalled its willingness to engage in negotiations with the ELN to end five decades of armed conflict.
Opponents of the talks have argued that a demobilisation of so many rebels at one time, most of whom have little experience of civilian life, would not be feasible.
But Mr Eder said "the Colombian government is ready" and had the experience and funds to deal with a mass demobilisation.
He pointed to his agency's expertise, gained over the past 10 years rehabilitating 56,000 former right-wing paramilitaries and left-wing guerrillas.
According to Mr Eder, the main challenge was to get the support of wider Colombian society and to make people realise the process would take time.
Reintegrating ex-combatants into society normally takes seven years, during which they receive extensive psychological support as well as educational and vocational training.
Lengthy process
The length of the programme depends on the background of each individual, 70% of whom are either completely illiterate or just barely able to read or write their names.
Their average age at the time of recruitment is 16, so few have had much formal schooling.
"They're coming from a completely different society and you essentially have to train them about everything," Mr Eder explained.
"You have to teach them how to cross the road, literally.
Colombian President Juan Manuel Santos (left) shakes hands with a member of the ELN guerrilla who has defected at a military base on 16 July 2013Colombia says any rebel who demobilises will be welcomed back into society
"You have to teach people how to stand in line at the bank, and how to pay [in a shop] because when you have an AK-47 slung over your shoulder, nobody wants to charge you," he says.
Apart from offering psychological help to overcome the trauma of years of jungle warfare, the programme offers educational support.
The main aim is to get all the participants through elementary school education, so they can go on to vocational training and take up jobs.
Mr Eder is particularly proud of one young former female Farc rebel who has made it to university, where she is studying medicine.
"She was forcibly recruited by the Farc when she was eight. She came out of the group at 17, illiterate, with all sorts of psychological problems, no family connections whatsoever," he recalls.
"We started working with her, [giving her] psychological attention, education, we found her family, rebuilt the family relationship and to cut a long story short, 10 years later she is studying in her third year of medicine!"
Mr Eder admitted the young woman was an exception but said it showed that the programme, which costs the Colombian government $90m (£55m) a year, was working.
Lure of illegality
But there are also those who relapse.
Ten percent of those who have gone through the programme have been tried and convicted of crimes committed after they demobilised, according to ACR figures.
Cocaine seized from the criminal gang Los Urabenos is displayed by the Colombian police on 20 April, 2013Astronomical profits in drug-trafficking lure some back into a life of crime
And Mr Eder puts the total number of those who have gone back into illegality at between 20% to 25%.
While rejecting allegations that Colombia's powerful criminal gangs such as the Urabenos and the Rastrojos are largely made up of demobilised right-wing paramilitaries as "a myth", he conceded that many of the top leaders of these gangs were former paramilitaries.
"In 2010, we identified 60 of the people who set up these groups. Half of them were former AUC [United Self-Defence Forces of Colombia] commanders."
According to Mr Eder, the lure of Colombia's most lucrative illegal export is hard to resist.
"You have to take into account that we're trying to end a conflict in Colombia that's fuelled by a highly illegal natural resource that is cocaine," he explained.
"When you pull people out of the conflict, there are going to be some people who say, 'Hey, shall I go into this reintegration programme, and go to the psychologist, and learn how to be a baker, or shall I manage this $20m-a-year drug route?'," he said.
"And unfortunately some of them opt for the $20m-a-year drug route.
"That's also why the Colombian police and the Colombian armed forces still have their work cut out for them, even once we demobilise all these people."

More on This Story